Susan Smith Boyfriend: Who Was Tom Findlay and What Did His Letter Say at Trial?

Tom Findlay was Susan Smith’s former boyfriend in Union, South Carolina, in 1994. A week before she killed her sons, Michael and Alex, he gave her a letter explaining why he did not want to pursue their relationship. Prosecutors later put the letter before a jury as evidence supporting their theory of motive. Findlay appeared as a witness at the trial. David Smith, the father who addressed the parole board again in November 2026, was Susan’s estranged husband at the time of the crime, a different man with a different role in the case.
How did Tom Findlay know Susan Smith?
Findlay’s father owned the company where Susan worked. Contemporary reports described a relationship that lasted several months while Susan and David were separated. In July 1995, when reporters in the Union courtroom were trying to explain who the witness was, that connection to her workplace and the timing of the separation helped place him in the family’s story. He was twenty-seven at the time the boys died. Susan was twenty-three.
At trial, the significance of their relationship came down to a fairly narrow period in the autumn of 1994. The prosecution wanted the jury to consider what Susan understood about the future of the relationship in the days before the deaths. There was a piece of evidence unusually well suited to answering part of that question. Findlay had put his thoughts into writing before there was any criminal investigation or any reason for him to prepare an account for jurors.
When did he write the letter?
Contemporary courtroom reports date the typed letter to October 17. Findlay gave it to Susan on October 18. On October 25, one week after she received it, her sons died in John D. Long Lake. Those dates are sometimes compressed into the statement that he wrote to her a week before the deaths. More precisely, a week separated the day she got the letter and the day the boys were killed.
Findlay wrote about qualities he valued in Susan, then explained why he did not want to continue the romance. One reason involved the prospect of helping raise children. Early coverage often pulled out a single short sentence on that subject. In court the jurors had a fuller document to consider. The immediate subject of his letter was whether he wanted to pursue a future with a woman who already had two sons, not what should happen to those children.
How did the prosecution use his words?
On July 19, 1995, prosecutor Tommy Pope read the letter to the jury during Findlay’s testimony. The prosecution argued that Susan saw her children as an obstacle to a relationship she wanted to continue. The phrase about children mattered to that argument because it came directly from the man she had been seeing. The short time between the letter and the deaths supplied a second element of the prosecution’s account.
The argument about motive still required an inference. Findlay could say what he had written and explain what he wanted from his relationship with Susan. He could not give direct testimony about every thought she had when she read the letter or during the days that followed. The jury was hearing a witness establish the circumstances of a breakup and prosecutors explain what they believed Susan had made of it. Those were two distinct steps in the presentation of the case.
Did Findlay testify that he wanted the boys harmed?
No. The reporting on his testimony describes a man saying he did not want to take on the responsibilities of a parent. It does not describe him asking Susan to harm Michael or Alex. Findlay was a witness in the proceeding against Susan. It was Susan who admitted that the boys had been in her car when it went into the lake and Susan whom the jury convicted on two counts of murder.
The defense offered a different account of her emotional state and challenged the idea that one failed relationship supplied a complete explanation for the killings. That disagreement is worth preserving when retelling the trial. A verdict establishes the offenses of which a defendant was convicted. It does not make every proposed explanation for the defendant’s thinking a separate factual finding. The letter remains evidence of a breakup and an important part of the prosecution’s interpretation of events.
Why did the case return to the news?
In November 2026, the South Carolina parole board held Susan’s second parole hearing. Its members had already denied release at her first hearing in 2024. On November 19, the board again voted unanimously to deny parole. David spoke about the loss of his sons, and Susan addressed him in her statement. The focus of that proceeding was her possible release after decades in prison. The board was not retrying the 1995 case or hearing the breakup letter as new evidence.
For someone coming to the story through the recent hearing, the simplest way to keep the two men straight is to follow the documents and the occasions. Tom Findlay wrote the October 1994 letter and gave evidence about the relationship in July 1995. David Smith was Michael and Alex’s father, appealed for their return when he thought they were missing and later attended the parole hearings to speak for them. Findlay’s significance in the public record remains tied to that letter and the testimony about what he meant when he wrote it.
