David Smith’s Children and the Family Behind the Hearing

David Smith’s Children and the Family Behind the Hearing

When David Smith spoke ahead of Susan Smith’s second parole hearing, he talked about the people helping him get through it. His wife, Tiffany, and his two adult children were among those he leaned on as he prepared to return to the South Carolina parole board. David and Tiffany said they planned to attend the Nov. 19, 2026, hearing and oppose Susan’s release. Two years earlier, their daughter Savannah had joined them in making that case.

For David, the hearings concern two children he lost and involve a family he built years later. Michael and Alex, his sons with Susan, died in 1994. His daughter Savannah and younger son Nicholas were born in the years that followed. David has spoken about all four in interviews over the past two decades. Those conversations tell the story of a father who once went on television to talk about his newborn son and, years later, found himself supported by the children he had watched grow up.

Who Are David Smith’s Four Children?

David Smith’s children are Michael, Alexander, Savannah and Nicholas. Michael and Alexander, whom the family called Alex, were his sons with his former wife Susan Smith. Savannah is his daughter with Tiffany Smith. Nicholas was born during a brief relationship David had with another woman, a detail he explained in interviews on CNN’s Larry King Live in 2003 and 2004.

The timing matters because most coverage of David begins with the deaths of his first two children. By 2003, when he appeared on CNN to talk about his family, he had recently married Tiffany and become a father again. Savannah was 2, and Nicholas had been born that January. David had spent years answering questions about what happened in 1994. That interview gave him a chance to talk about what was happening in his life at the time, down to a detail many new parents are eager to share. Both children had red hair.

Why Is Savannah Part of the Parole Story?

Savannah was born years after Michael and Alex died. She grew up knowing their story through her family, and in November 2024 she took part in a hearing connected to their deaths. According to Us Weekly, she joined David and Tiffany in asking the South Carolina parole board to keep Susan in prison. The board unanimously denied Susan’s request.

It was a rare public appearance for a daughter David had first talked about when she was a toddler. During his 2003 CNN interview, he described Savannah as fun and smart. In another appearance the following year, he recalled meeting her mother at the grocery chain where he worked. At that point, his public comments about Savannah were the sort of things a father might tell someone who asked how his family was doing.

By 2024, Savannah was old enough to decide for herself whether to be part of the hearing. Her participation is one of the few publicly reported details about her adult life. The family’s announced plans for the 2026 hearing centered on David and Tiffany, who said they would attend and again urge the board to deny release.

What Has David Smith Shared About Nicholas?

David introduced Nicholas to television viewers in July 2003, several months after his birth. He spoke about having a healthy baby boy and joked that the red hair both younger children inherited might have come from his great-grandmother. In March 2004, he mentioned Nicholas again during a conversation about his family with Larry King. He explained that Savannah and Nicholas have different mothers.

David also credited Nicholas’s birth with helping him make a decision he had put off. He and Tiffany had dated on and off after the deaths of Michael and Alex. The idea of marrying again meant learning to trust someone after a period in which so much had gone wrong. David told CNN that he started thinking seriously about taking that step within days of Nicholas being born. By the time of his July interview, he and Tiffany were married.

Public details about Nicholas largely come from those early interviews. In November 2026, David spoke more broadly about the support he received from his adult children and Tiffany. What began as a conversation about two small children had become a conversation about the adults he could turn to during a difficult week.

What Does David Remember About Michael and Alex?

Michael was 3 years old when he died, and Alex was 14 months old. In an interview with People ahead of the 2026 hearing, David said much of his time with the boys had become hard to recall clearly. A few things stayed with him, especially the way Michael spoke. He remembered Michael’s pronunciation of 101 Dalmatians, his favorite movie, and the way he said “brother” when referring to Alex.

David keeps a few photographs at home. One family picture published with the interview shows him holding the boys. He also said visitors still bring toys and other small items to their gravesite. Some of those visitors had never met Michael or Alex. David said it meant a great deal to him that people continued to make the trip.

What Happened in 1994, and Why Was There a Second Hearing?

Michael and Alex died on Oct. 25, 1994, in Union County, South Carolina. Susan initially claimed a Black man had stolen her car with the boys inside. She appealed for their return, and the search drew national attention. Nine days later, she admitted that she had let the car roll into John D. Long Lake with the children inside. A jury convicted her of two counts of murder in 1995, and she received a life sentence.

Under the South Carolina law that applied to her sentence, Susan could seek parole after 30 years. Her first opportunity came in November 2024. David spoke against her release, and after the board denied it, he said he would keep opposing future requests for as long as he could. The law allowed Susan to apply again two years later, leading to the hearing scheduled for Nov. 19, 2026.

David’s interviews ahead of that hearing gave readers a glimpse of what those years have held for him. In 2003, he remembered crying when Savannah and Nicholas were born and spoke candidly about how their arrivals changed his life. In 2026, he spoke about leaning on his family and about the people who still bring toys to Michael and Alex. After all that time, one of the details he remembered best was the sound of his oldest son’s voice saying he had a little brother.